Sabbourati

Fractions: Why 1/4 Looks Bigger Than 1/3

Pupils compare fractions as if they were whole numbers. Sharing, equivalent fractions and common denominators: a progression to fix that habit.

“4 is bigger than 3, so 1/4 is bigger than 1/3.” This reasoning turns up in almost every class. It is not silly: the pupil is applying what they know about whole numbers. The whole job is to show them that, with fractions, this habit no longer works.

More pieces, smaller pieces

Start with a real sharing situation. Cut one flatbread into 3 pieces, then an identical one into 4 pieces. Which piece would you rather have? Pupils see straight away that sharing among more people gives each person less. The denominator tells you how many pieces the whole is cut into: the bigger it is, the smaller each piece.

Paper strips of the same length give the same experience on a table: one strip folded into 2, another into 4, another into 8. Line them up and compare the pieces.

A fraction is one number

A fraction is written with two numbers, but it stands for just one. To make this stick, have pupils place fractions on a number line from 0 to 1, then beyond. They see that 3/3 lands on 1, 2/3 comes before it and 4/3 after it: comparing the numerator with the denominator tells you whether a fraction is greater than 1.

Equivalent fractions before common denominators

Cut each half of a strip in two and you get quarters: 1/2 = 2/4. Cut each half in three and you get sixths: 1/2 = 3/6. The rule “multiply the numerator and the denominator by the same number” then becomes a description of what was done with the scissors, not a formula to memorize.

To compare 2/3 and 3/4, look for a way of cutting both strips into the same pieces: twelfths. 2/3 = 8/12 and 3/4 = 9/12, so 3/4 is larger. Start with cases where one denominator is a multiple of the other, such as 2/3 and 5/6, before cases where a common multiple has to be found.

Fraction FlashEquivalent fractions, simplifying, common denominators: the first to find the answer stops the Gobbler.See the game

Three mistakes to watch for

A four-step progression

  1. Share objects and paper strips, and name the pieces.
  2. Make equivalent fractions by cutting the pieces again.
  3. Compare fractions with the same denominator, then rewrite fractions with a common denominator.
  4. Order fractions and place them on a number line.

Finding a common denominator means finding a common multiple of both denominators, which makes it a good moment to review multiples.

The Tile WorkshopMultiples, factors and divisibility with mosaic tiles to arrange in rectangles.See the game

From the blog